Russia: Religion will soon become obligatory at school

Russia: an Orthodox Russian girl at school. In 2010 school-children were officially allowed to wear religious clothing in schools

Editorial note: In quite a few European countries, Religion is an obligatory subject at school. For example in Sweden, or Ireland, where “religion is taught in a subject called Religious Education which is compulsory in many schools for the Junior Certificate, but available as an option for the Leaving Certificate”; but also in the U.K., as “Religious Education (RE) is a compulsory subject in the state education system in the United Kingdom. Schools are required to teach a programme of religious studies according to local and national guidelines.” (from Wikipedia) Malta, UK, Sweden, Iceland, Norway and Denmark – have religion as a compulsory subject with no other alternative offered, while in other European countries non-believers are often offered ethics as an alternative. For example Slovakia, which is “generally a religious country of Christian religion. The latest research results show that 84% of inhabitants are religious and Christians attend Mass and practice their religion in everyday life. There are catholic schools in Slovakia including primary schools, secondary schools and universities and Religion for religious children is a compulsory subject in primary schools. For the non-religious children their parents can choose Ethics as an alternative subject. Slovakia values freedom of religion” (From Slovakiasite). Now Russia is going to join them.

Russia: Children in an Othodox Church

Obligatory religion (Original Title from The Voice of Russia)

From The Voice of Russia
By Milena Faustova

Photo: RIA Novosti

From September 2012, fundamentals of religion will be introduced as an obligatory subject in all schools of Russia. According to their own (or, probably, their parents’) choice, schoolchildren, starting from the 4th or the 5th year, will study fundamentals of Orthodox Christianity, Islam, Judaism or Buddhism (these denominations have been officially recognized “traditional for Russia”), or a course which shortly tells about the history of all these religions. Those who will not want to study religion will be able to attend alternative classes of secular ethics.

A decree which outlines the details of teaching this new subject was recently signed by Russia’s Prime Minister Vladimir Putin.

The initiative to introduce such a subject in schools came as long as about 10 years ago from the Russian Orthodox Church, but it was only in 2009 that this subject was introduced in schools in 19 regions of Russia as an experiment.

Since the very beginning, this idea came under criticism of quite many people in Russia – mainly, atheistically-minded ones. Their main arguments, in fact, may be reduced to two major ones. First, Russia is a secular state where no religion may be an official or obligatory ideology. Second, Russia is a state of many religions and many nationalities, and dividing people into groups according to their religion may stir national and religious hatred.

Religious education in Russia

“I believe that it would be wrong to divide children from a young age into groups according to their denomination,” expert in religions Ivar Maksurov says. “This may cause many problems.”

“I am not against introducing this subject in schools,” Mr. Maksurov continues, “but not in its present form. I believe, it must be thoroughly revised.”

Another problem that the introduction of the new subject is now facing is the lack of well-qualified teachers and good textbooks. There have been several attempts to write a school textbook on fundamentals of, say, Orthodox Christianity, but neither of them has won the approval of the Ministry of Education.

Russia: Muslim school children with their teachers for religion

“A good textbook is, of course, needed,” Honored Teacher of Russia Evgeny Bunimovich believes, “but what is even more needed is good teachers. With a good teacher, a lesson of fundamentals of religion may become a good lesson of religious tolerance.

However, Russian religious leaders do not share the skepticism of the new subject’s secular opponents. Knowing more about one’s own and one’s neighbor’s religion cannot stir religious hatred, the religious leaders assure. On the opposite, the more a person is educated in the sphere of religion, the more tolerant he or she is to other people’s opinions.

Mufti Albir Krganov, the Chairman of the Spiritual Board of Moslems of Chuvashia (an autonomous republic within Russia), says:

“Experience has shown that in Chuvashia, the new subject has become very popular both with children and with their parents. Sometimes, parents say that they themselves have learned more about religion because their children have such classes. At the same time, a secular school should remain secular. But studying religion can bring nothing but good.”

From February, additional courses for teachers of the new subject will be opened in Russia. And in March, parents will have to decide the fundamentals of what religion their child will study (or whether he or she will study secular ethics). Besides, a website will soon appear where the latest news concerning this subject will be published.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Russia: Religion will soon become obligatory at school

  1. toadspittle says:

    .

    “Russia: Religion will soon become obligatory at school” screams the headine.
    Blimey!
    Good story!
    But then, in only the third sentence we read, “Those who will not want to study religion will be able to attend alternative classes of secular ethics.”

    This from a website which delights in moaning about how the biased media “distorts” Catholic stuff, and is plotting to destroy everything we hold dear.

    Like

  2. JabbaPapa says:

    I spent 4 of my school years in a Catholic private school which was at the time run by some rather warmhearted nuns, and even there I was able to opt out of the religious education classes.

    I was an agnostic at the time, though I didn’t fully understand the nature of it.

    It’s possible that my fairly radical refusal of a passive approach to this religious education was a blessing in disguise, following my father’s idea that faith is an adult notion ill-served by indoctrination ; my approach of the Faith is certainly one that is divorced from any overly childish subservience ; but then OTOH, my siblings are atheists, including one very radical one (the more violently atheistic denizens of Damian’s DT blog frankly pale in comparison) and another (atheist) who attended this particular school four years longer than I did …

    I don’t know what the moral of my story is.

    Like

  3. toadspittle says:

    .
    Toad, also, often wonders what the moral of his stories is.

    But he is gratified to see, from the accompanying photo, that Rasputin has been disinterred (¡Miracle!) and put to work with the kiddies. Who are suitably impressed, as we can see.

    Like

  4. toadspittle says:

    .

    STOP PRESS: Proposed new headline:

    “Russia: Religion Will Soon Be Obligatory At School – Unless, Of Course, You Don’t Want Your Child To Take Religion, In Which Case He or She Can Simply Opt For “Secular Ethics” (whatever the heck they are) Instead”

    Toad humbly appologises for his apparent and glaring error. (New headline is a tiny bit “wordy” but better safe than sorry, eh?)

    Like

  5. Patricia says:

    Wow! And we have freedom of religion? I think not!

    Like

  6. Patricia says:

    And the student’s desks are actually facing the front of the class and the teacher. There is a normal blackboard on the wall, too. What novel ideas. Maybe we should try them.

    Like

  7. toadspittle says:

    .
    Patricia says:
    “Wow! And we have freedom of religion? I think not!”
    …but what does she mean?

    Re: The topic:
    Toad supposes that it will soon be obilgatory to teach religion in Russia, but not obligatory to learn it.
    Gogol would have been amused.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s