Pope to Traditional Catholic writer: Your criticism were made in love

From Rorate Caeli: 

“Yes, it’s true. I received the telephone call by the Pope. It happened two weeks ago, November 1st, All Saints. But I naturally kept it to myself. No one was supposed to have known it, it was a conversation of an absolutely private nature. But considering that the [news] agencies have mentioned it…”
Mario Palmaro, the Italian traditional Catholic writer and journalist who has authored many books and articles together with his friend Alessandro Gnocchi (many of which have been posted in translation here on Rorate) told Italian daily Libero about the fact. In September and October, after a very critical article published in Il Foglio, Palmaro and Gnocchi were summarily fired by Catholic broadcaster Radio Maria after several years of work in the station.
The phone call, Libero describes, was first reported by Traditionalist website Papale Papale with no mentioned names, and then by VinoNuovo, which mentioned Palmaro, who is currently very ill, by name.
Palmaro’s declarations to Libero on the matter are all mentioned below:
“It bothers me that the news has been made public, and if it had been up to me, and Alessandro, to whom I revealed it immediately, it would never have been known. Also because the Pontiff obviously had no intention that his gesture be made public, as well as the contents of our conversation”.
“Pope Francis told me that he was very close to me, having learned of my health condition, of my grave illness, and I clearly noticed his deep empathy, the attention for a person as such, beyond ideas and opinions, while I live through a time of trial and suffering.”
“I was astonished, amazed, above all moved: for me, as a Catholic, that which I was experiencing was one of the most beautiful experiences in my life. But I felt the duty to remind the Pope that I, together wih Gnocchi, had expressed specific criticisms regarding his work, while I renewed my total fidelity [to him] as a son of the Church. The Pope almost did not let me finish the sentence, saying that he had understood that those criticisms had been made with love, and how important it had been for him to receive them.” [These words] “comforted me greatly.”
[The main duty for Palmaro and Gnocchi] “is that of being lucid and watchful regarding the contents of the Catholic doctrine, and, even in what we wrote in Il Foglio, fidelity to the Pope was never called into question.”
[Palmaro says that] “the removal of the interview granted by Pope Francis to [Italian journalist Eugenio] Scalfari from the Vatican website makes us think that something was wrong in the contents of that text, as we had remarked, among other things.”
“Our intention is that of keeping steady on the path that we have always followed, answering before our conscience. This without ever faltering in fidelity to the Pope and the Church, but precisely because of this fidelity and love.”
[Excerpts within quotation marks taken from Libero and rearranged by Rorate Caeli; via Cristianesimo Cattolico. Tip: Twitter followers. Follow @RorateCaeli on Twitter and share your opinion with them.]
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Pope to Traditional Catholic writer: Your criticism were made in love

  1. johnhenrycn says:

    “When you express too much, you run the risk of being misunderstood,” said Pope Francis in his September interview with Antonio Spadaro, S.J. All the more reason, I suggest, not to speak extemporaneously. After that interview, many Catholic commentators hastened to point out that His Holiness had said nothing to contradict Catholic doctrine, and I believe they are right, but still, many serious Catholics were left wondering: ‘what’s he on about?’, especially when organizations like the National Abortion Rights Action League gave him an effusive “Thank you… [from] pro-choice women everywhere…”, as did the LGBT Human Rights Campaign group.

    Pope Francis, God bless him, has not repealed Catholic doctrine (as if he could), but he makes it clear where his priorities lie – with the poor and downtrodden – and in a way that hints that those on the front lines of the abortion and gay marriage wars ought to rethink their own priorities.

    Encyclicals are wonderful teaching documents. Not so interviews with the press.


  2. Toadspitttle says:

    All very mysterious.
    How did the traditionalist website Papale Papale find out about the phone call, then? (Or am I missing the obvious?)


  3. kathleen says:

    Very perceptive comment JH, that sums up this difficult situation in every respect.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s