Reprinted by kind permission of the Author.
By DONAL ANTHONY FOLEY
The Franco-Prussian War, which began in 1870, was the backdrop to this silent apparition of Our Lady at Pontmain in northwestern France. By January 1871, the country was in a very serious position militarily, with the Prussians controlling two-thirds of the country and Paris besieged. It seemed to be only a matter of time before Mayenne and Brittany, the northwestern part of the country, would also be taken.
The next attack was expected at Laval, the capital of Mayenne, less than 30 miles from Pontmain, where the Blessed Virgin would appear.
At the time, Pontmain was a small village, inhabited by simple and hardworking country folk, who, guided by their parish priest, Abbé Michel Guérin, sought to live as good Christians. The Barbedette family consisted of father César, his wife, Victoire, with their two sons, Joseph and Eugène, aged ten and twelve, and another older brother who was away in the army.
On January 17, 1871, after going to early morning Mass, the boys spent the day at school as usual. On their return, they were helping their father in the barn when a neighbor, an elderly lady named Jeannette Détais, called in and began to talk with César. During the conversation, the older boy, Eugène, walked over toward the door to look out, and noticed one area practically free of stars above a neighboring house.
This puzzled him; but, as he gazed at it, suddenly he saw an apparition of a beautiful woman smiling at him; she was wearing a blue gown covered with golden stars, and a black veil under a golden crown.
As Jeannette Détais was about to leave, Eugène asked her if she could see anything, and as she replied in the negative, his father and brother came out to look. Joseph immediately said he too could see the apparition, although their father, like the old lady, saw nothing. He asked Eugène if he could still see the Lady and on being told “Yes,” asked him to go and fetch his mother.
Victoire arrived but like the other adults she could see nothing, although she was puzzled because her boys were usually very truthful. She suggested that it might be the Blessed Virgin, and that they should all say five Our Fathers and five Hail Marys in her honor.
By this time the neighbors were coming out to see what was going on, and the Barbedettes withdrew into the barn to pray. The family servant, Louise, was called but she too could see nothing; and as it was now about a quarter past six, the family went inside for supper. Victoire gave the boys permission to go out again soon after, and, on hearing that the Lady was still there, went to fetch Sr. Vitaline, the local schoolteacher.
Eugène pointed to three bright stars in the shape of a triangle and told her that the Lady’s head was in the middle of them. Although Sr. Vitaline could see the stars, she saw nothing else, and so she went to get three young girls from the school to see their reactions. Immediately they arrived, the two youngest of these, aged nine and eleven, expressed their delight at the apparition, describing it as the boys had done, although the oldest girl saw nothing. The three stars were seen by everyone that evening, but disappeared after the apparition.
It was decided to fetch other children, and another sister called at the presbytery to tell Fr. Guérin, who, after some hesitation, decided to come out as well. As he reached the barn with his housekeeper, a child of two and her mother had just arrived. Immediately the infant looked with delight at the apparition, clapped her hands, and called out the name of Jesus, as taught by her mother. The next evening the child was taken back to the same spot at the same time and told to look, but gave no indication of seeing anything.
The adults in the crowd, which had now grown to about 60 people, including the priest, could still see nothing and began to say the rosary, as the children exclaimed that something new was happening. A blue oval frame with four candles, two at the level of the shoulders and two at the knees, was being formed around the Lady, and a short red cross had appeared over her heart.
As the rosary progressed, the figure and its frame grew larger, until it was twice life size; the stars around her began to multiply and attach themselves to her dress until it was covered with them.
As the Magnificat was being said, the four children cried out, “Something else is happening.” A broad streamer on which letters were appearing unrolled beneath the feet of the Lady, so that eventually the phrase, “But pray, my children,” could be read. Fr. Guérin then ordered that the Litany of Our Lady should be sung, and as this progressed new letters appeared, making the message, “God will soon answer you.”
As they continued to sing, another message was formed, one that removed any doubt that it was the Blessed Virgin who was appearing to the children: “My Son allows Himself to be moved.”
The children were beside themselves with joy at the beauty of the Lady and her smile, but her expression then changed to one of extreme sadness, as she now contemplated a large red cross that had suddenly appeared before her, with a figure of Christ on it in an even darker shade of red.
One of the stars then lit the four candles that surrounded the figure, as the crucifix vanished and the group began night prayers. As these were being recited, the children reported that a white veil was rising from the Lady’s feet and gradually blotting her out, until finally, at about nine o’clock, the apparition was over.
Our Lady Of Hope
It is worth noting that earlier that evening, at the house near Paris where Catherine Labouré — the seer of Rue du Bac and the Miraculous Medal — lived, the sisters observed the remarkable color of the western sky, which some felt was an omen. Catherine looked but said nothing, although later, when the events of Pontmain became known, it was suspected that she had some inkling of what had happened.
In any event, it appears that she certainly believed that our Lady appeared there, since she said as much to a fellow nun in 1872, telling her to send her prayer intentions to the village, because “the Blessed Virgin revealed herself there.”
The following March a canonical inquiry into the apparition was held, and in May the local bishop questioned the children. The inquiry was continued later in the year, with further questioning by theologians and a medical examination.
The bishop was satisfied by these investigations, and in February 1872 declared his belief that it was the Blessed Virgin who had appeared to the children. Joseph Barbedette became a priest, a member of the Congregation of the Oblates of Mary Immaculate, while his brother Eugène became a secular priest. One of the girls who had seen Mary assisted him as his housekeeper, while the other, Jeanne-Marie Lebossé, became a nun. A large basilica was built at Pontmain and consecrated in 1900.
During his reign, Pope Pius XI confirmed the decision of the bishop and granted a Mass and Office for Pontmain under the title “Our Lady of Hope.”
(Donal Anthony Foley is the author of a number of books on Marian apparitions, and maintains a related website at http://www.theotokos.org.uk.)
What a lovely story. I’ve never read about this particular apparition of Mary. She is amazing. God bless. Ginnyfree.
Pontmain was the first Marian shrine I visited after my reception into the Catholic Church in 1992 in Mortain, Normandy. I went there on a day pilgrimage with the Community of the Beatitudes from the Abbaye Blanche in Mortain. The village and the basilica were covered in snow and there was a special silence about the place which snow always brings. The experience made a great impression on me, as did the local cider which was very powerful stuff…
You surely aren’t suggesting the kiddies were on the scrumpy, Rabit?
Yes, it is a very lovely story.
But what was the point?
“God will soon answer you.”
Well, did He?
If so, what was His message to the nippers? “My Son allows Himself to be moved.”? Well, that will just have to do, I suppose.