Switzerland: An “explosive” publication before the Synod on the Family

More dissension this time from the Swiss. Please pray for the participants in the Autumn Synod.



In Switzerland, in view of the upcoming Synod on the Family, a work presents the portraits of five families committed to the Church, including a female “couple”. Written in Swiss German by Arnd Bünker and Hanspeter Schmitt, it is entitled Familienvielfalt in der katholischen Kirche (Diversity of Families in the Catholic Church). According to Apic on July 28, 2015, the work unsurprisingly comes to the conclusion that “most Catholic ecclesial communities in Switzerland are very open to the alternative forms of families that exist in present day society.” The book also includes “discussions with specialists on science and pastoral theology, as well as reflections on the questions of gender and rites.”

In the July 15 edition of the Zurichese newspaper Neue Zürcher Zeitung (NZZ), journalist Simon Hehli, voiced the idea that the work’s goal is “to take the opposite view of the more conservative positions” of the bishop of Chur, Bishop Vitus Huonder, on the family. This claim was denied in the same edition on July 28 by Daniel Kosch, secretary general of the Central Roman Catholic Conference of Switzerland (RKZ).

Daniel Kosch explained that the book’s goal is “to document the reality of the diversity of families and to arouse awareness of the challenges the Church has to face.” According to him, the book draws attention to the “urgent need for a further development of the proclamation of the Church’s message, her ethics and her juridical order.” For the secretary general of the RKZ, “the pastoral practice and the language of the Church should take into account the fact that the situations of couples and families of believers and faithful are more diverse and more fragile than the Church in this country is often willing to admit.” Daniel Kosch grants that the publication is potentially “explosive”, as Simon Hehli suggested.

The work written by Arnd Bünker, director of the SPI (Swiss Institute of Pastoral Sociology), and Hanspeter Schmitt, professor of theological ethics at the High School of Theology of Chur (THC), was funded by the “ecclesiastical corporations” of the cantons of Zurich, Argovia, Lucerne, Nidwald, Saint-Gall and Bâle-Campagne, known for their intemperate progressivism.

The bishop of Bâle spoke out in a long interview broadcasted on July 26 by the Zurichese weekly Schweiz am Sonntag. Without directly mentioning the work in question, Bishop Felix Gmür wished that the Church would “go out of herself to go towards people.” And he claimed: “On the level of my personal belief, I can imagine women at the altar.” The head of the largest diocese in Switzerland declared that the ecclesial communities and parishes should “act on the level of the important social issues, be it through concrete acts to protect the climate or in the matters of immigration and the changes in the structure of the population.” The prelate declared he is “convinced that we have to discern what preoccupies the faithful” and wants to believe despite the alarming official statistics that the Church in Switzerland “continues to grow”.

(sources: apic/blick – DICI no.319 dated August 7, 2015)

Read also :
Synod on the Family : The Rhine will not flow into Lake Volta
Cardinal Sarah’s clarifications on the upcoming synod
Persistent tensions surrounding the Synod on the Family

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Switzerland: An “explosive” publication before the Synod on the Family

  1. 000rjbennett says:

    The Church in Switzerland “continues to grow”?

    Bishop Gmür would do well to pay attention to those “alarming official statistics.”

    If what he wants were ever to become a reality, those statistics would become only more alarming, as they have here in Germany.

    Are these prelates never going to understand that “to go towards people,” means conforming more to the world, instead of making the world conform to the Church’s teachings? In the last fifty years, since Vatican II, this “going to the people” has been a disaster for the Church: closed seminaries, disbanded parishes, pedophile priests, disappearing religious orders.

    And these Swiss bishops – and others – want even more of that? Are they deliberately trying to destroy the Church – or are they just stupid?

  2. Michael says:

    Bishop Felix Gmür wished that the Church would “go out of herself to go towards people.” And he claimed: “On the level of my personal belief, I can imagine women at the altar.”

    There is a missed opportunity here for the Anglican Communion – clearly there exist large numbers of people who also, whilst essentially liberal Protestant in their views, enjoy pretending to be Catholic. I implore Justin Welby to begin missionary work in Germany and Switzerland as soon as possible!

  3. geoffkiernan says:

    I think it is only fair that Mr A Bunker is allowed to make a contribution to this ,very serious of matters…After all he will be in good company

  4. johnhenrycn says:

    I always use to like Archie Bunker. I never knew he was Catholic:

  5. toadspittle says:

    I know you and I disagree on this, JH – but just because Archie looks like a Catholic – it doesn’t make him one.

  6. geoffkiernan says:

    Toad, after much time trying to picture you, its strange ( or not) that, he, Archie is exactly what I thought you would look like. With or without the hair perhaps…

  7. toadspittle says:

    Wrong, Geoff.
    Compared with Toad, Archie is as beautiful as Mel Gibson.
    Toad is utterly hideous.
    (Except to other toads. And not always then.)

  8. Brother Burrito says:

    I just found this:


    You’re not hideous Toad, just nicely menacing 😉

  9. johnhenrycn says:

    Ha, ha! So cool! A bit like one of my literary heroes:

    …but not at all like one of his:

  10. toadspittle says:

    One on the other..
    “The striking thing about Mencken’s mind is its ruthlessness and rigidity… Though one of the fairest of critics, he is the least pliant….”
    What ought I to read by Wilson, JH?

  11. johnhenrycn says:

    Do you need to ask? To The Finland Station, about revolutions and socialism, and Patriotic Gore, about the American Civil War, are the most famous, but he also, like HLM, was a prolific essayist and critic.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s