Beware the Error of Those Who Proclaim Mercy Without Repentance

After the latest moves announced by Pope Francis for the coming ‘Year of Mercy’, and with our anxious sights on the October ‘Synod on the Family’, this clear, insightful article by Msgr. Pope on the real meaning of Mercy, and the conditions for it to be granted, should help clear up a lot of reigning confusion.  

Those who preach and teach mercy without repentance are deceivers, and are likely deceived themselves

By Msgr. Charles Pope on the National Catholic Register

kk201509021131-605x317 As we prepare for the Year of Mercy, a blessed declaration from our Holy Father to be sure, permit me to express one concern. Fundamentally it concerns a flawed notion of mercy that is widespread in the world today, and also to some extent in the Church.

A simple way of describing the problem is to say that one of the great errors of our day is the proclamation of mercy without repentance, without reference to our sinful condition. So many pulpits have gone silent on sin! And therefore they are silent on the true glory of mercy and the astonishing gift that it is! Ah, mercy! Divine mercy! Perfect mercy! But only when we know and acknowledge our sins can this joyful cry be deep and authentic.

Yet too often today mercy is preached in a detached way and is taken by many to mean that our sins aren’t really sins, or are no big deal, and that God doesn’t really care what we do because, after all, he is merciful. And, by contrast those that do speak of sin are thereby unmerciful and mean.

Thus yet again we must state the critical and central truth that the astonishing and glorious mercy of God is accessed by repentance. It is repentance that opens the door to mercy, forgiveness, and kindness.

Consider a medical analogy of a man who is in very poor health. Perhaps he has a host of problems such as hypertension, high cholesterol and diabetes. Now modern medicine has a lot to offer people who are struggling with poor health. The healing help includes everything from medicine to surgery, to information on nutrition, etc. But in order for this man to access that healing help, he needs to realize and admit he has a problem, schedule an appointment, keep the appointment, take the medicine and follow the advice he receives.

Now, when he does this, AND ONLY when he does this, will the healing help of the medical profession unfold for him. It is not enough for him to say, “Well isn’t it great that there are doctors and medicine out there.” That is not enough. He has to make a change and actually reach out and develop a relationship with the medical community. He has to actually take the medicine. It is not enough to praise the medicine and rejoice that healing is available; he has to act and set a new course for his life.

And this is an analogy for the spiritual life and repentance. God’s offer of mercy and healing love stand, and are offered to everyone. But these magnificent gifts must be accessed through repentance.

The Greek word that is usually translated as repentance is metanoia and it means more than simply to clean up our act. Most literally it means to come to a new mind, or a new way of thinking. The “meta” in metanoia signifies change. So repentance involves more than a sorrow. It involves actual change or a move or a step in the right direction. And in this way metanoia (repentance) unlocks all the blessings the healings, the mercy, and the salvation that is promised. We must allow the grace of God, interacting with our freedom to effect an actual change, a decision in our life that changes the way we think, the way we act, and puts us into a saving relationship with the Divine Physician Jesus.

Repentance is the key that unlocks mercy. We need to recouple mercy with repentance.

  •  Isaiah had said, The Redeemer will come to Zion, to those in Jacob who repent of their sins,” declares the LORD (Is 59:20).
  • And to the Disciples in Emmaus Jesus said, Repentance for the forgiveness of sins will be preached in his name to all nations, beginning at Jerusalem. (Luke 24:46-48)
  • St. Paul warns, In the past God overlooked such ignorance, but now he commands all people everywhere to repent (Acts 17:30)

    Thus those who preach and teach mercy without repentance are deceivers and likely themselves are deceived. And those who think of mercy without reference to repentance are deceived.

    Repentance is the supernaturally transformed and assisted human element that is necessary to unlock mercy and the graces of God. To ignore or deny this amounts to a denial of human freedom and does not help God’s people. Rather it hinders them, for mercy is accessed through repentance, and without it, the door cannot open.

    But the point of the call of repentance is not simply to go out and tell others how terrible they are, but rather to tell them about the forgiveness of sin! And this is why we need a Year of Mercy! On the one hand we’re living in rebellious times, times in which many are dismissive of sin and have refashioned God into just a nice fellow who doesn’t really care all that much about sin (despite what His own Scriptures say to the contrary), reducing mercy to mere kindness and a sort of blindness of a doting God.

    On the other hand, these are also times when many are scared and angry with God, rejecting His judgments and glorious moral vision. A lot of people know that their lives are in disorder: their families are broken; they are confused; greed, materialism, lust, and other sinful drives are taking a heavy toll. And many are angry with the Church because deep down they know the Gospel is right. They don’t like being reminded that people have no business calling good what God calls sinful.

    But most of all, many are confused and angry because they don’t know forgiveness. All the more reason to preach the glory of mercy experienced through repentance. For indeed, if we do not know the bad news, the good news is no news.

    So let’s celebrate this Year of Mercy, but do it in the only way that truly unlocks its power and highlights its glory: Repentance for the forgiveness of sin is to be preached to all the nations beginning at Jerusalem! (Luke 24:48)

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Beware the Error of Those Who Proclaim Mercy Without Repentance

  1. Mimi says:

    What an excellent article from the ever-insightful Monsignor Pope!

  2. Michael says:

    Agreed – an excellent (and very clearly laid out, as always) post from Monsignor Pope! His post at his own blog of yesterday is really good as well:

  3. A brilliant article. However, will Kaspar and others find some way of manipulating the synod into ignoring the need for real repentance, real metanoia, as a means of obtaining mercy?

    I’m sure Kaspar and the other Germans are going to try. They will attempt to blind as many of the synod fathers as possible, so that these good bishops – not to mention our poor Pope himself – simply do not see that adulterers and sodomites have to be sorry for their sins and change their lives, if they expect to receive mercy and the Eucharist.

    It sounds so obvious, so clear, so simple, and yet the ability to obfuscate the truth is one of the many fruits of evil.

    And when the truth is made hard to see, the gates of hell are then so very much closer to prevailing.

  4. Michael says:

    I’m sure Kaspar and the other Germans are going to try.

    I’m sure they are going to try too. But why be so confident that they will succeed? The Church has been through plenty of trials in the past, and plenty of times it looked like sin and error would prevail – but they didn’t, because Our Lord promised they would not.

  5. 000rjbennett says:

    Why “so confident”?

    It’s not confidence, Michael. It’s fear.

    And if I’m wrong about this, if Kaspar and his supporters lose their influence with the Pope and are defeated, believe me, I will be the happiest man in the world.

  6. Michael says:

    It’s not confidence, Michael. It’s fear.

    Well, why the fear then (of their ultimate victory I mean)? We have been given promises that the gates of hell will not prevail, and the Church has survived countless assaults against her teaching throughout the ages without its being altered, so why be so persuaded that Kasper et al will have their way?

    I don’t say that it won’t potentially be messy, or that there won’t be forceful attempts by those who wish to change Church doctrine, but ultimately our faith in the Holy Spirit’s ability to work through all this and steer the ship safely, must be greater than any fear of the evil men do. On top of that, I personally think Kasper (plus others) played their hand far too early last October – they caught people (relatively) unawares last time, but this time around the faithful at the Synod (and they are many) will be prepared for any tricks.

    Kasper’s arguments have been exposed and shown to be lacking, and the tactics of people like him and Baldisseri could not be used again without a huge outcry amongst the cardinals at large. Furthermore, any attempts to force through things without the support of a required number of cardinals will also be subject to enormous scrutiny from outwith the Synod itself. It’ll be a trying time, no doubt, but we must remain confident in God and the way He has always preserved Truth in His Church, even amidst great pressure by the men within it to do otherwise.

  7. kathleen says:

    Robert John Bennett @ 10:58 said:

    I’m sure Kaspar and the other Germans are going to try. They will attempt to blind as many of the synod fathers as possible…

    They will indeed; you have confirmed that they have already started putting their un-Catholic ideas into practice in many parts of Germany.
    However, Michael draws our attention to a significant consideration: that Kasper & co. “played their hand far too early last October”, catching the rest of the Synod bishops more or less off-guard. This time, as he says, they (the good traditional bishops) will be ready and waiting for them. I was just reading the other day about the overwhelming number of wholly orthodox African bishops from the flourishing Church there, who have signed some sort of manifesto supporting the Church’s traditional teachings on Marriage and the Family. Let’s hope they will have a say at the Synod too.

    So much will depend on the Pope’s final words though. We should pray fervently that the Holy Spirit will guide and protect him at this vitally important moment of his papacy.

    Michael…. like Robert, I admitted in the introduction to Msgr. Pope’s article my (and that of many Catholics’) anxiousness on how “mercy” will be played out at the October Synod. But your inspiring and calming words of good sense and hopefulness have done much to allay my own ‘fears”. 🙂

  8. Michael says:

    Kathleen @ 13:43, September 3rd:

    Thank you! Believe me, I have plenty of fears about how the Synod will pan out as well, and I imagine Kasper etc will certainly try their hardest to remodel the Church into something else; but yes, we must put our faith in the One who has the final say on the direction His Church will take – to whom else will we go? 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s