Echoes of Vatican 2

From Rorate Caeli:

Synod, Day 6 – Final Relatio in danger; Rules changed by the hour – Microphone denied to Erdo, as to Ottaviani in Vatican II

Since before the Synod, there were doubts about a specific post-synodal papal exhortation, but there were never any doubts that there would be a final Relatio voted by the Assembly. Not anymore! The votes must be in doubt on the side of the manipulators, because since Cardinal Tagle first mentioned the possibility that there might be no final document at all in yesterday’s press conference, that has been the general talk.
Plus, there is complete disarray in the order of works. While Cardinal Erdo, formally the Relator-General, should be presenting his reports on the second and third parts of the Instrumentum Laboris, the floor has simply not been yielded to him anymore. Not at all! The third part of the Instrumentum, with its most controversial portions (on “remarried” divorcees and homosexuals) is now being openly debated without so much as a clear order of works. As we indicated on Day 2, the Estates-General have become the National Assembly, and the Jacobins are running the show.
Italian journalist Sandro Magister has the details in his Italian-language personal blog:

But this is not all [that is: the news about the new denial of the Final Relatio]. Because on October 10, Father Lombardi gave the news of another change occurred in this work in progress.
According to the Synod calendar, the discussion in the Hall and in the small groups were to follow the order of each of the three parts of the basic document, the Instrumentum Laboris, with each of them introduced each time by a “presentation of the Relator-General”, Cardinal Peter Erdo.
Instead, Cardinal Erdo — author on October 5 of a remarkable introductory general report that sowed panic among the innovators — was not given the microphone to return to present the three parts of the Instrumentum, and the interventions in the Hall went ahead on their own. With the result that, on Saturday, October 10, the [debate on the] Third Part [of the Instrumentum], has already begun in the Hall, the most attractive [part], with the strong dishes of divorce and homosexuality, while in the language groups the discussion should have still been centered on the Second Part of the document until Wednesday 14.
On October 10, Father Lombardi said in seraphic tones that an account of the interventions in the Hall ahead of time, those dedicated to the Third Part of the Instrumentum, would be given to reporters a few days later. In order for them not to be confused.
That the microphone has been denied to Cardinal Erdo so that he could have early direction of the presentation of each part of the Instrumentum Laboris by the direction of the Synod (let us be clear, by Cardinal Baldisseri, certainly directed by the Pope himself, it could be otherwise, it could simply not be otherwise), recalls one of the most tragic events in Vatican II, when Cardinal Ottaviani, the Prefect of the Holy Office had his microphone cut by Cardinal Liénart. It set the whole tone for a revolutionary council.
Vatican III is here, and the rules are changed at whim.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Echoes of Vatican 2

  1. A friend wrote to me:

    “What we are seeing is the end of the Church as we know it.

    “The Church will survive among a few faithful Catholics around the globe, but what now comprises ‘the Church’ will become increasingly irrelevant, as it continues to conform more and more to the World.

    “Eventually, that ‘Church’ will disappear, and only a small number of true Catholics will remain. That is the way in which Christ’s promise will be fulfilled, and the gates of hell will not prevail.”

  2. Michael says:

    Some interesting points in this EWTN report, including discussion of the problems with the new process and its lack of transparency, and the problems with the Instrumentum Laboris (preeminent amongst these problems being that it leans heavily towards problems facing the West, and ignores the realities being faced by families in the rest of the world, who haven’t given in to secularisation, and which, lest we forget, make up the vast majority of the Catholic Church). Also, there is a good interview with Cardinal Napier in the last ten minutes of the video:

  3. Michael says:

    P.S. As a disclaimer, there is a strange bit of hero-worship of Cardinal Tagle shown by both the host and her guest (both of whom otherwise show no other signs of favouritism during this interview). I feel that I must also add a further disclaimer that this is a sentiment I do not share myself 🙂

  4. Gertrude says:

    I remember what subsequently became ‘the Ottavianni intervention’. It shamed the perpetrators who denied him a voice and it shamed Holy Mother Church. I did not imagine that I would live to see the same thing happen again. Shame on those Synod Fathers who denied Cardinal Erdo the opportunity to speak.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s