Plea to the pope: Life and family leaders call on pope to ‘end the confusion’

CP&S Comment: This post will come as no surprise to the majority of faithful Catholics the world over. The growing concern at the reigning confusion caused by uncertainty at the real meaning behind the pope’s words in his interviews, homilies, and above all in his recent exhortation on the family ‘Amoris Laetitia’ has reached breaking point. A formal, once-and-for-all clarification without ambiguities is being pleaded for by the Church’s bishops and leaders.

ROME, July 13, 2016 (LifeSiteNews) — In a spirit of love, humility, and faithfulness, 16 international life and family advocates are asking Pope Francis in a powerful new video to unambiguously speak the truth of the Catholic faith, to end doctrinal confusion, to restore clarity, and to be the Holy Father that Catholics need.

“We are living in a very special time of a deep crisis of faith inside the Church,” said Bishop Athanasius Schneider, the Auxiliary in the diocese of Maria Santissima in Kazakhstan, who opens the video, produced by LifeSiteNews.

“It is not a secret. It is very evident. A lot of people, the simple faithful, are suffering because of the situation of confusion,” he added.

The 30-minute film, titled Plea to the Pope, comes in the wake of confusion caused by the pope’s April release of his Apostolic Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, in which he made a number of concerning statements about marriage, divorce, sin, reception of Holy Communion, and sex education for children. The Exhortation has generated numerous contradictory interpretations from various theologians as well as cardinals and bishops.

Bishop Schneider called it “very urgent” that the pope “states more clearly, in a very unambiguous manner — in such a manner which will not leave any space for misinterpretations — [on] the issues of family and the sacredness of marriage.”

The film contains an impressive lineup of international life and family advocates who decided that the time had come to voice their concerns for the good of the Church, of souls, and of nations.

Some of those featured in the video are:

– John Smeaton – President, Society for the Protection of Unborn Children Co-founder, Voice of the Family

– Colleen Bayer – Papal Dame in the Order of St. Gregory the Great President, Family Life International New Zealand

– John-Henry Westen – Editor-in-chief, LifeSiteNews, Co-founder, Voice of the Family

– Prof. Thomas Stark – Benedict XVI Academy of Philosophy and Theology University of St. Polten, Austria

– Christine Vollmer – Vatican’s Pontifical Academy for Life, Founding member, Founder, Latin American Alliance for Life

– Preston Noell – Director, American Society for Tradition, Family, and Property

– Molly Smith – President, Cleveland Right to Life

– Prof. Roberto de Mattei – Professor, European University of Rome Founder, Lepanto Foundation

– Dr. Thomas Ward – Founder & President, National Association of Catholic Families, Corresponding Member, Pontifical Academy for Life


Many of the supplicants begin their concerns with a statement of love and fidelity to the divinely instituted Office of Peter and its current holder. They assure the Holy Father of their love and their prayers.

“I love the Holy Father. I pray for him every day,” says LifeSiteNews’ Editor-in-Chief John Henry Westen in the film. “And I [raise these concerns] out of great love for the Church. But we need to work for Christ and his truth. And I need to defend my own family, and [statements he has made are] a threat to the faith of my children.”

Westen says that there has been too much “purposeful ambiguity” in the pope’s interviews and documents.

“There’s been a lot of ambiguity, purposeful ambiguity, leaving things open so that there is confusion. And I think that it does a great deal of harm. You have this scenario where people start to wonder what exactly the teaching is. This is a horror – that Catholics, who believe and love the faith, are now confused on the fundamentals of the faith in these areas where the teaching means life or death, and I don’t mean only physical life or death; it means eternal life or death.”

John Smeaton, President of the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children, begins his plea by expressing his “reverence” for the pope and ends by stating that he prays for the pope “every day.”

“I say this with huge reverence for the Holy Father and with attention to common advantage. What he has written is justifying adulterous acts. We are already hearing of couples who, on the basis of what you have written, Holy Father, have decided to give up their heroic virtue and fall into objective mortal sin, and to come forward to receive the body and blood of Jesus Christ.”

“How is it possible to reconcile what you have written with the teaching of the Church, with a tradition of the Church?” he said in the film.

In response to Pope Francis’ February tacit approval of contraception in response to concerns about the Zika virus, Christine Vollmer — a founding member of the Vatican’s Pontifical Academy for Life and fonder of Latin American’s Alliance for Life — stated that the Catholic Church “will be destroyed” if it accepts contraception.

“Contraception has destroyed a number of churches already. Today, the Anglican Church is empty. They have few vocations. And it’s because this vital connection between the love of a husband and wife and the love of the Church — the love of God and trust in his providence — was broken in the Anglican Church. And now it would seem that it is being broken in the Catholic Church, in spite of Paul VI’s agonized, but inspired, encyclical Humanae Vitae.”

“I just implore [the Pope] to speak about the importance of the numerous family and the dangers of the contraceptive mentality. Teach our bishops that they must stand strong and they must explain that the contraceptive mentality destroys families, it destroys countries, and it will destroy our Christian civilization,” she said.

One supplicant expressed concern that the recent Synods on the Family and the Exhortation that came from them, rather than helping the family that is “under attack” instead had the effect of “gasoline being thrown on the fire.”

“We see that the family is under attack. It is in a state of crisis,” said Preston Noell, the Director of American Society for Tradition, Family, and Property.

“The situation only becomes worse, however, when added to the fact that the family is crumbling, some people — including some Catholics, maybe even a large number of Catholics — come to think or believe that marriage can be dissolved – which of course, it cannot be.” Speaking of Amoris Laetitia he said, “Instead of receiving what we would hope to find, a buttressing and strengthening of the sacred institutions of holy matrimony and marriage-and-the-family, we see something like gasoline being thrown on the fire.”

“This is very troubling to us. What we would really hope to see is that this would be turned around. We need to pray to the Holy Ghost to inspire the Church, to inspire our leaders, to inspire the Holy Father — as I mentioned, for whom I pray every single day — to help turn the situation around, to strengthen the family. Because if not, I fear we perish,” he said in the film.

Historian Roberto de Mattei, a professor in the European University of Rome and the founder of the Lepanto Foundation, called Amoris Laetitia a document of “catastrophic consequences.”

“The terrible impact of this document is that many souls are today in a deep crisis of conscience. There is the possibility that a great number of souls will lose their eternal life. In my view, the true life is, above all, the spiritual life. More than the physical life, the spiritual life of souls is today in great danger. We have to react against this,” he said.

Bishop Schneider concluded the film with an appeal to the faithful for prayers for the Holy Father.

“And so, let us pray for our Holy Father, whom we love, that he may have the courage to speak with the same clarity and with the same courage as Christ spoke, as Peter spoke,” he said.

URGENT: Sign the pledge to pray for Pope Francis every day. Click here.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Plea to the pope: Life and family leaders call on pope to ‘end the confusion’

  1. Michael says:

    I always assumed that infallibility prevented him from clearly teaching in accordance with his beliefs.

  2. A brilliant, brilliant action on the part of LifeSiteNews. It demonstrates that the pope is infallible ONLY when he speaks officially, ex cathedra, on matters of faith and morals. The First Vatican Council issued decrees on this question and Blessed John Henry Cardinal Newman wrote about it extensively, as others have done. The pope is most certainly NOT infallible when he speaks off the top of his head at a press conference or in another informal setting, even when he gives a sermon at Mass or during the Angelus.

  3. kathleen says:

    I totally agree with you, RJB – this is a magnificent and courageous undertaking on the part of LifeSiteNews. The question is now, what will come from it? At least we may presume that with so many important members of the hierarchy and laity joining their voices in this “plea” for clarity, he cannot ignore the issue any longer!

    Will the pope now reconsider his vague and (IMO) calculated ambiguous form of talking and writing, or will he deny it exists? Will his close aides and personal theologian make suggestions on how to rectify the situation and re-write the contentious parts of AL that have sparked so much of the lamented “confusion”, or not? Will the pope be angry and feel slighted at such a ‘daring’ action on the part of these faithful members of the Church (that he will see as ‘traitors’)and instead turn on them in rage with his arsenal of ready-made insults? Or will he be touched by Grace and surprise us all with a recognition of the errors pointed out, and put himself to righting them?

    Loads of questions, but the answers won’t be coming along any time soon, I fear.

  4. toadspittle says:

    “We need to pray to the Holy Ghost to inspire the Church, to inspire our leaders, to inspire the Holy Father…”
    I seem to recall being told, when young, that The Holy Ghost was actually responsible for selecting the pope via the conclave of cardinals. Not so, it seems. (And I might well recall wrongly.)

    “Contraception has destroyed a number of churches already. Today, the Anglican Church is empty. They have few vocations. And it’s because this vital connection between the love of a husband and wife and the love of the Church — the love of God and trust in his providence — was broken in the Anglican Church.”
    Nonsense. I don’t believe the Anglican church has had much to say against contraception. The Catholic Church has, and many Catholics just cheerfully ignore it. Most people enjoy kids, but they don’t necessarily want dozens of the little rascals. Matter of taste.
    …Like with dogs. I like a lot of dogs. Others more sensible are content with just one.

  5. I always thought he was infallible at 30.000 ft. Being closer to God and all that

  6. toadspittle says:

    “I always thought he was infallible at 30.000 ft. Being closer to God and all that”

    Heaven’s up there somewhere. Just to the top left of Venus, possibly.
    Hell, on the other hand is somewhere underneath us, but above New Zealand.
    Tom will confirm this.

  7. Robert says:

    Its a mistake to see two different people (public and private with the Papacy) or even to talk of infallibilty in specific terms. Ignoring the casual or even so called private opinions. That is not what the Gospels or Bible tell Us. Our Lord was very specific about the spoken words as the revealing the Heart of a man.

    Matthew 15
    11 Not that which goeth into the mouth defileth a man: but what cometh out of the mouth, this defileth a man.

    Luke 6
    45 A good man out of the good treasure of his heart bringeth forth that which is good: and an evil man out of the evil treasure bringeth forth that which is evil. For out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaketh.

    The promise of God speaking through His Prophets. In every Age there are always Prophets in the world. God does nothing except first revealing his secrets to His Prophets. The Popes are nothing if not Prophets.

    Amos 3
    7 For the Lord God doth nothing without revealing his secret to his servants the prophets.

    Luke 1
    70 As he spoke by the mouth of his holy prophets, who are from the beginning:

  8. katusablog says:

    Reblogged this on katusablog and commented:
    Great confusion often arising from “Official” writings of His Holiness

  9. katusablog says:

    Thank you, Robert, for the various Biblical cites, especially when considering comments we often hear these days from His Holiness.

  10. johnhenrycn says:

    katusablog says: “Great confusion often arising from “Official” writings of His Holiness.

    I see that she didn’t place her scare quotes around His Holiness. That’s a start.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s