15 Cloisters Dissolved: What Remains of the Order of the Franciscans of the Immaculate?

It has been a long time since any further news of developments within the situation of the once flourishing Order of the Franciscans of the Immaculate have come to light. Now Katholisches has produced this report (translated by Tancred) published on The Eponymous Flower. The tragedy continues.

What Remains of the Franciscans of the Immaculat

What Remains of the Franciscans of the Immaculate

(Rome) How far has the destruction of the Order of the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate progressed? This is the updating of a chapter that is like a dark shadow on the pontificate of Pope Francis.

In 1969 two Fathers Minor, Stefano Maria Manelli and Gabriele Maria Pellettieri, asked the Father General of the Order, after a thorough study of Fontes Franciscani, to be allowed to start a “new experience of Franciscan life” back to its original rigor. In 1970 an abandoned monastery of the Order was made available to them where they gathered more men over time, and with the establishment of a female branch, women also joined. In 1990, the Community was canonically recognized as a separate order.

The Peculiarity of the Young Order

The Order represented an anomaly of Catholic orders until July 2013. While the old religious orders steeped in tradition suffer decline and waste away, the young Franciscan Order saw a veritable blooming of vocations.

Its peculiarity was that the founders did not turn to liberal openings after the Council, but returned to the rigor of the Franciscan ideal. The sensibility which unfolded there led to a return to the traditional rite under Pope Benedict XVI. The Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate were thus the only new rite order, which moved to the traditional form of the Roman Rite and the rigor of its life, attracted many young people, while other orders starved.

The particularity which defined this Order as community of the old rite, is that it did not belong to the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei, but the Roman Congregation for Religious, which is otherwise only concerned with the new rite.

The two founders of the Order: Fr. Stefano Maria Manelli (left) and P. Gabriele Maria Pellettieri

The two founders of the Order: Fr. Stefano Maria Manelli (left) and P. Gabriele Maria Pellettieri

Another peculiarity distinguished the young, blossoming order from the Ecclesia Dei– communities. Besides the charism of the order, the Franciscan ideal of Marian devotion, love for tradition and the traditional rite, there was a missionary zeal.

While the Ecclesia Dei communities are enclosed in garden preserves, where in some dioceses they are tolerated more than accepted, the Franciscans of the Immaculate had the freedom of new rite communities to openly develop their apostolates freely and to be especially active in mission.

With its turn to the old rite, the first difficulties began with the diocesan bishops. Of the three known friaries established in German-speaking countries, only Kitzbühel (Archdiocese of Salzburg) established in 2002, was successful. The two other, more recent attempts (diocese of Bolzano-Brixen, and Linz Diocese) were rejected.

The Reversal Upon the Election of Pope Francis

The young religious order enjoyed papal benevolence under Benedict XVI., which suddenly changed under Francis. In July 2013, just four months after his election, the Religious Congregation completely overturned the order’s leadership with papal approval. The Order was placed under provisional administration. The Commissar, Capuchin Father, Fidenzio Volpi, who was no friend of the traditional rite, began a veritable destruction. Father Volpi, who died in June 2015, was replaced by the Salesian and canon lawyer, Sabino Ardito. The destruction of the Order has continued nevertheless, unabated.

Reasons for radical intervention in the blossoming religious were still not known. Behind closed doors the Commissioner and the head of the religious congregation confirmed that which observers had suspected from the start: The reason was the aforementioned feature of the Order. A new rite order, which had moved to the traditional rite, attracted numerous vocations of young people and aroused growing attention from other new rite orders, which began to be interested in this “success story”, could not be.

The decree by which the provisional government was established, only contained a detailed determination. But it revealed the thrust of the action: Despite anything to the contrary that had been issued by Benedict XVI. with the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum, it was determined that no priest of the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate be allowed to celebrate the traditional rite any longer. Anyone who wished to celebrate the old rite had to make a private application, which had to be approved by the Commissioner. More contempt for the traditional rite could not be demonstrated.

Under Pope Benedict XVI. it had not been possible for hostile forces to take action against the order. With the election of Pope Francis, who commented disparagingly in June 2013 about traditional circles, the situation had changed in one fell swoop.
Because of his power, Pope Francis prevented that the leadership of the order could turn to the Apostolic Signatura against the actions of the Congregation of Religious. The order had no legal recourse. It had to endure.

No Benevolent Father

Since the beginning of the act of dismemberment, 14 monasteries were dissolved by the commissioners. Currently, even the dissolution of the monastery of Florence is being prepared, which was a center of the order before the provisional administration. It will be the 15th Monastery closure since the beginning of the provisional administration. The commissioners have proven to be employed against the order not as benevolent fathers, as Cardinal De Paolis was, whom Benedict XVI. placed at the top of the Legion of Christ in 2010 when the order had fallen into a spiral by uncovering of the double life of its founder.

The commissioners of the Franciscans of the Immaculate were employed, rather more like liquidators. Three and a half years after his establishment at the Legion of Christ, Cardinal De Paolis ended his administration with the election new leadership for the order. There is no end of the apostolic administration for Franciscans of the Immaculate. The poignant question now arises, what will then be left of the former order?

Alfonso Bruno and His Campaign

With the death of the first Commissioner, at least, the influence of Father Alfonso Bruno seems to have declined. Alfonso Bruno was the Media Representative of the order’s earlier leadership. He is considered the real brains behind the rebellion against the founders and the charism of the order. Officially, he does not seem to be among the five brothers, who had turned to the Congregation of Religious with a letter to complain against the exclusive use of the traditional rite in the order. In the concern for pastoral care, the order had actually remained biritual. Yet the letter was the incentive to intervene by the Congregation of Religious.

Commissioner Volpi appointed Alfonso Bruno Secretary General and was influenced by him. Otherwise, the Commissioner had made false claims against Founder Stefano Maria Manelli, for he was convicted of defamation in a state court judgment. The execution of punishment was kept from him only by his unexpected death. The new Commissioner, Ardito, did not make the same mistake obviously. While Volpi was the sole Commissioner, Father Ardito has employed a Jesuit and Capuchin as assistants besides. He thus has dispensed with a General Secretary and sent Alfonso Bruno in September 2015 to be the head of a religious house in Messina, Sicily. However, he is set to continue his campaign against the former Superior General, Father Manelli, who was deposed in 2013. He is, according to rumors, behind a blog which is called “The Truth about the Provisional Administration of the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate” and is only overflowing with malicious articles.

Abolition of the Fourth Marian Vow

Meanwhile, the first vows were conducted without the typical consecration to the Immaculate Heart of Mary in Brazil and the Philippines. It was replaced by a simple expression of willingness to go on mission. The consecration to Mary is a fourth vow a characteristic of the order. In addition to the three evangelical counsels of poverty, chastity and obedience, which is common to all religious communities, the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate make a fourth Marian vow which precedes the others.

The abolition of the consecration to Mary is the second concrete imposition upon the charism of the order. “It raises the question: Was this consecration the problem? And if not: Why do you force upon the order such a change of its original charism,” wrote Libertà e Persona.

The canon lawyer continues to debate whether the Decree of the Congregation of Religious of July 2013 is at all lawful or not. Opinions vary. The same applies to specific interventions such as the abolition of Consecration to Mary. Some canonists think that such an intervention could be resolved legally only by the General Chapter of the order. Again, opinions differ. Since Pope Francis forbade the courts to hear the discussions of the canonists, whatever conclusions they reach, for now, have no actual impact.

Forbidden Reestablishment

Since the provisional administration, numerous brothers have wanted to leave the Order. They want to maintain the lifestyle to which they have committed themselves through their vows. The planned start-up of an old rite order was banned by the Congregation of Religious. It’s another indication that it is opposed to tradition and the traditional rite. Commissioner Volpi threatened the bishops not to allow Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate, leaving their order. At the same time he presented accused those “entrusted” to him, of wanting to overthrow Pope Francis.

The brothers want to remain faithful to their consecration to Mary, the full devotion to the Immaculate. Its abolition represents a serious encroachment on the identity of the order. It is a cause of uncertainty and anger that there is no recognizable connection between the abolition and the introduction of the provisional administration.

According to credible sources this intervention is to be extended to the female branch and thus also to the Franciscan Sisters of the Immaculate to place them in a moral dilemma, who have vowed loyalty to a particular charism that has been accepted and confirmed by Pope John Paul II in 1998. The media always finds new horror stories to publish about the Order. Comparable hate campaigns had appeared in the German language are endured by the Opus Dei, the Engelwerk that Auerbacher SSND and also includes The Work. Monastery walls seem to inspire outlandish fantasies not only for journalists.

With the cloister in Florence, 15 convents have been closed. The provisional administration is leaving a veritable trail of destruction.

60 brothers have officially asked to be released from their vows to leave the order. Since Rome fears the establishment of a new order, the applications are not being accepted. The majority of them have been blocked for almost three years. As this path has proved a dead end, more brothers have given up an application.

Papal Centralism

With a Rescript ex audientia from April 4, 2016, which was made public only last May 11th, Pope Francis has revoked the previously self-evident right in church history of the right of diocesan bishops to recognize new religious communities. On June 1st received the approval by the Holy See. With the Rescript, Francis noted that the establishment of an order by a diocesan bishop without the consent of Rome is null and void.

The centralization ordained by Francis is the exact opposite of the other “decentralization” represented by him for the Church is as it carried out concerning the nullity of marriage, where the diocesan Bishop alone can decide today, or aiming for the admission of remarried divorcees to Communion.

Bishops close to Francis confirm, as the progressive magazine Il Regno reports, that although much of collegiality and synodality is talk, that the concentration of power in the hands of the Pope had never been so great in Church history.

Libertà e Persona presented the question in this context: “Is a federation of the Congregation for Religious preparing a common formation for all religious orders with their different charisms? Is a leveling of all charisms into a sort of syncretism of religious life what is desired? “

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to 15 Cloisters Dissolved: What Remains of the Order of the Franciscans of the Immaculate?

  1. kathleen says:

    So much talk about the ‘Year of Mercy’ all the time, but where is that mercy for the truly Catholic order for the faithful Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate?


  2. GC says:

    The Order represented an anomaly of Catholic orders until July 2013. While the old religious orders steeped in tradition suffer decline and waste away, the young Franciscan Order saw a veritable blooming of vocations . . . the rigor of its life attracted many young people, while other orders starved.

    An old Australian friend informed me some years ago that, in fact, the friars in Australia were able to get hold of an emptied Sisters of Mercy convent in a town called Toodyay (I’m not at all sure how to pronounce that) in the Archdiocese of Perth and converted it into their friary. (I’m told that for eastern Australians Perth is a small settlement slightly off the coast of Madagascar.)

    Likewise, the Oratory in Formation in the Archdiocese of Brisbane got a disused convent of the Australian Sisters of St Joseph, often known as the “Josephites for Justice.” One benefit of the Spirit of Vat 2 outfits is they now have many consequently vacated convents that can be used by religious orders and congregations that are actually growing.

    I don’t know if the friary in Western Australia is one of those to be dissolved. Their website does not seem as active as it used to be. Perhaps our friend Geoff Kiernan knows?


  3. Pingback: 15 Cloisters Dissolved: What Remains of the Order of the Franciscans of the Immaculate? — | Solutio Problematis Omnes (aka "The Catholic Linker")

  4. Roger says:

    St Francis
    For several years Francis searched the Scriptures, talked with friends and spiritual advisors, and prayed long hours in churches, woods and caves listening to God’s call and purpose for his life. Then one day in the church of San Damiano, a chapel right outside of Assisi, he heard the invitation of Jesus: “Francis, go rebuild my Church, which you see is falling into ruins.” “Yes!” said Francis. “This is what I want, this is what I long for with all my heart.”
    With that he gathered a group of brothers, gave them a few Gospel texts for their rule of life, and sent them out like the disciples of Jesus to live and announce the Good News of God’s love.


    With St Pio Heaven gave Us the first Priest with the Stigmata (St Francis had the Stigmata).

    Personally I abhor spin and PR, in flight press conferences and in general the praise of the world. St Francis never sought such worldliness.

    Matthew 7
    [15] Beware of false prophets, who come to you in the clothing of sheep, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
    [16] By their fruits you shall know them. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
    [17] Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit, and the evil tree bringeth forth evil fruit. [18] A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can an evil tree bring forth good fruit.
    [19] Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit, shall be cut down, and shall be cast into the fire. [20] Wherefore by their fruits you shall know them.
    [21] Not every one that saith to me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven: but he that doth the will of my Father who is in heaven, he shall enter into the kingdom of heaven.
    [22] Many will say to me in that day: Lord, Lord, have not we prophesied in thy name, and cast out devils in thy name, and done many miracles in thy name?
    [23] And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, you that work iniquity. [24] Every one therefore that heareth these my words, and doth them, shall be likened to a wise man that built his house upon a rock,
    [25] And the rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and they beat upon that house, and it fell not, for it was founded on a rock.
    [26] And every one that heareth these my words, and doth them not, shall be like a foolish man that built his house upon the sand,
    [27] And the rain fell, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and they beat upon that house, and it fell, and great was the fall thereof.
    [28] And it came to pass when Jesus had fully ended these words, the people were in admiration at his doctrine.
    [29] For he was teaching them as one having power, and not as the scribes and Pharisees.


  5. Toad says:

    “Personally I abhor spin and PR, in flight press conferences and in general the praise of the world. St Francis never sought such worldliness.”
    Quite right, Robegert- if there had been press conferences back then, St Francis would not have attended them.
    “A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can an evil tree bring forth good fruit.”
    Who created “evil” trees, then? God, surely?. Because He created everything, we all agree.
    He even created Satan, who “created” evil. as God already knew he would.
    So, it all would appear to be God’s fault in the first place.
    (No! That can’t be right!)


  6. JabbaPapa says:

    Despite anything to the contrary that had been issued by Benedict XVI. with the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum, it was determined that no priest of the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate be allowed to celebrate the traditional rite any longer.

    This is very exaggerated.

    Summorum Pontificum specifically subjects the ability in religious Orders of their clergy to publicly provide the TLM to authorisation by the relevant Authorities.

    Meanwhile, priests of the FFI do give such public TLM Masses, in such obedience, despite sundry opposite claims.

    The situation with the FFI is certainly non-ideal, but there can be no justification in presenting unhappy situations of 3-4 years ago falsely as if nothing has changed since.

    Particularly in view of several requests by the FFI themselves to refrain from interference in their internal affairs.


  7. johnhenrycn says:

    “…refrain from interference in their internal affairs.”

    Fair point. I read the same thing a while back, Jabbers. Let them clean up their own mess.

    As usual, I find John Kehoe’s opinion ( set forth above) crystallizes my own views on this mess.


  8. kathleen says:

    Jabba @ 17:39

    “The situation with the FFI is certainly non-ideal, but there can be no justification in presenting unhappy situations of 3-4 years ago falsely as if nothing has changed since.”

    It is not false. And the only change is the worse-than-ever situation in which they find themselves. I know this for a fact.

    Two members of the FFI from their house at Gosport joined us on the Chartres pilgrimage this year. I was blessed to be able to talk to one of them, in between praying and singing, as we ate up the miles. (He was an elderly man and could not keep up with our group; I fell back with him to keep him company.) I asked him how the difficult situation of his Order stood now, and although he was very discreet, criticising no one in particular, he gave me to understand that they had been severely messed up, and continue to be so. His pain and sorrow were evident. The friars based at Gosport are virtual prisoners, in some way that I don’t completely comprehend. Apparently they may only celebrate the Traditional Latin Mass if they remain at Gosport! If they move anywhere else they would have to celebrate the N.O. Mass! They choose to remain there so that they may continue to offer this beautiful Mass of the ages, despite this curtailing the projects and good work many of them were involved in previously.

    Those “several requests” to not get involved in their “internal affairs” were made at the beginning of the process of Papal interventions into the FFI. In true humility and obedience they submitted themselves to the Pope’s decision, asking all Catholics who were (understandably) angry and indignant at the Pope’s interference through his Commissioner, to not get involved. I doubt though that any of them could have imagined this upsetting situation would have gone on for so long.


  9. johnhenrycn says:

    ‘Nuff said. I trust Kathleen’s eyewitness report. Don’t know if Kehoe does.


  10. JabbaPapa says:

    he gave me to understand that they had been severely messed up

    This was clearly the case anyway, or the situation off the FFI would not be in the news, and my impression is that there was internal dissent upsetting the life of the Order.

    I would hope anyway that when required to provide the Novus Ordo, the Friars do so in a beautiful Latinate manner.


  11. mmvc says:

    Kathleen @ 00:16
    I’m glad you set the record straight on this. Thank you.
    God bless the faithful FFI members and their founder in their ongoing trials!


  12. JabbaPapa says:

    Just in case anyone was wondering why the FFI was placed into disciplinary oversight, this absolutely horrendous, utterly uncatholic, and satanically evil-minded “sermon” should clarify things :



  13. GC says:

    jabba, investigations seem to indicate that the site you linked is connected with a sedevacantist bishop (?), not in communion with Rome.


  14. JabbaPapa says:

    OK thanks GC, my bad.


  15. kathleen says:

    The FFI has many enemies. Even some liberal-leaning Catholics will often try to discredit them, perhaps due to the FFI’s clear preference for the beautiful Tridentine Mass and Latin Liturgy! The FFI are faithful Catholics who abide by the fullness of Catholic belief and practice, not only in its doctrines and dogmas, but also in their great love for the Blessed Virgin Mary, and all the Church’s pious devotions. This niggles the more progressive crowd in the Church, and it is probably the main reason the Vatican-appointed Commissioner still holds control, whilst their situation continues unresolved.

    The four or five rebel members who originally denounced them to the Vatican, out of their community of hundreds, complaining the Order was becoming too traditionalist, should feel shame and remorse at the outcome of their underhand deed. (Why did they not simply leave and join a more liberal Order?) Certain sympathisers in the Vatican took the side of the traitors, and the result has been a heart-breaking near total destruction of a once flourishing Catholic Order that was doing tremendous good and attracting loads of new vocations to the religious life.


  16. With this new Pope Only God’s know what will happen next not just for the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate but for any other Orthodox Religious community out there. It is palpable to see how to the left is this Pope and with those withing the Church who only desire is to see it come down. But history has proven that such individuals in the Church only plays with fire. We the Church must remain faithful to the truth.”as the Truth will set us free”. If the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate and any other religious order is dismantle by liberal Catholics in the Vatican, let it be. Perhaps the desire of St. Francis not to establish a religious order was a premonition of what was to come in the future meaning our times.

    The Tree must be shaken and let all the rotten fruits fall so that the good fruit may continue to strive to do the Good it has been doing for God’s Kingdom. Know Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate and any other faithful Religious Catholic Order that we stand with you and we pray that our Lord will do its justice at do time. For now let all this be a time of purification and to continue to grow in holiness.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s