Is Facebook listening to your Confession?

Is Facebook listening to your Confession?

By Diane Montagna

VATICAN CITY — As our smartphones become smarter and social media expands, so does the risk that your privacy will be increasingly breached.

In light of this, how much of a danger is it to bring your smartphone into the confessional? And what precautions can priest and penitent take?

“All phones have a microphone, and Facebook and many other phone apps require access to the microphone and camera,” said Fr. George Hajj, parish priest at St. Anthony of Padua Maronite Church in the United States. “Therefore we don’t know what technology, and in whose interest it is in, to spy and overhear what is being said in the confessional.”

For Father Andrew Pinsent, Research Director at Oxford’s Ian Ramsey Centre for Science and Religion, surveillance through modern technology has become so thorough that it makes Orwell’s Big Brother fears look almost quaint, like “something from the dinosaur era.” It therefore demands “extra vigilance” to ensure “proper privacy in regard to the sacraments, when matters of salvation are at stake.”

Fr. Pinsent covers cameras “that can be turned on electronically” to prevent snoopers (FBI director James Comey recently advised people to do the same thing). He also has other concerns such as built-in microphones on computers as well as mobile devices (as does Mark Zuckerberg), and the general profiling that comes with browsing. He calls e-assistants like Siri and Amazon’s Echo “simply insane from a privacy perspective.”

The problem is magnified all the more, he adds, since “a staggering variety of low-cost spyware for sale” exists which allows anyone, government or individual, to “glean information” if they are determined to do so.

Yet more and more priests are taking their phones into the confessional, because they find the portability and ease of a smartphone more practical for praying the Divine Office than carrying a hardbound book. Similarly, penitents sometimes prefer to use a phone app to make an examination of conscience before their confession, and often they bring that app with them into the confessional, to easily reference their sins.

Read the rest here

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Is Facebook listening to your Confession?

  1. JabbaPapa says:

    This is an article that should be of little concern to most, for the present time anyway, but nobody who for any reason may be under any risk or reality of outside electronic surveillance, even where that surveillance may be beneficial and freely (or implicitly) agreed to, should ever discuss anything of private and confidential nature in the presence of a microphone attached to a battery.

    The thing about phones, tablets, and laptops etc. is that there is a battery incorporated into the electronics of these devices, running the internal clock and other things, so that even switching them off and removing the general battery does not provide full protection against snooping, but only removing these devices from your presence can do so.

    For most people though, simply switching them off is an adequate protection.

    These things are of course a matter of concern for those engaging in any form of public “activism”, political or otherwise. This of course includes priests. These men should be consciously aware of these risks, and should in some circumstances take stronger precautions.


  2. johnhenrycn says:

    I never carry a mobile into church, let alone into a confessional booth.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s