All but five of the 39 Little Sisters of Mary, Mother of the Redeemer, a conservative French religious order, have been relieved of their vows by the Vatican after refusing to submit to a group of Vatican-appointed commissioners led by a habitless liberal nun who wanted to impose “modern orientations” on the group, in the sister’s words.
The 34 nuns, who dress in traditional habits and care for the disabled and elderly in four different nursing homes, have been asked to relinquish their facilities and their religious dress now that they are no longer considered members of their institute. The fate of the nursing homes and their residents is now in question.
The ruling comes from the Holy See’s Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life, which oversees religious orders and institutes, led by Cardinal João Braz de Aviz. Previous attempts by the sisters to overturn the congregation’s rulings against them by appealing to the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura have failed, with the court reportedly dismissing their case without allowing them to fully present their arguments.
“Having looked to remaining faithful, as much to the Church as to the charism granted by Our Lord to Mother Marie de la Croix, having tried to find, many many times, a path of dialogue with Rome, having offered peaceful solutions, no agreement having been found, the authorities in Rome in charge of the Consecrated Life have now decided to choose to release us from our religious vows,” the sisters announcedon June 3, following the issuance of the decision on May 23.
“Whilst it is true that in the context of the moral pressure and the impasse that we found ourselves in, we were driven, last October, against our profound wishes, to ask to be released from our vows, since no other solution had ever been offered to enable us to remain in communion with the Church: we are profoundly wounded by this and remain sadly surprised that Rome has preferred to accept that request rather than accepting the peaceful solutions which we had put forward and which were possible,” the sisters added.
The lay-led Association in Support of the Little Sisters denounced the decision as a “grievous injustice” and blamed the bishop of the Diocese of Laval, Thierry Scherrer, for a personal vendetta against the group’s conservative mother superior that has now led to the destruction of the order.
“Mgr Scherrer wanted the head of the Superior General on a platter,” wrote the association. “An entire Congregation has been destroyed!”
“This unjust and violent decision gives rise to grave damage both moral and material to the Little Sisters of Mary who have given their lives in the service of the Church, in perfect fidelity to their religious vocation,” they add.
According to their lay supporters, the sisters were accused of a variety of offenses against modern sensibilities, including engaging in “too much prayer,” the use of the traditional habits, “deviant authoritarianism,” being “too classical” in their thinking, and being “unmoving” in their adherence to the charism of their institute. They also say the commissioners tried to turn the sisters against each other, offering prestigious positions in the order if they would conform to the commissioner’s authority, but their tactics failed. When the nuns refused to admit the commissioners, they were threatened with excommunication and requested to be relieved of their vows to avoid that outcome.
The support association says the decision to relieve the sisters of their vows instead of working out a solution with them came at the behest of Sr. Geneviève Médevielle, the principal apostolic commissioner named by the Vatican. Médevielle is a religious sister who dresses in lay clothing and wears a short haircut without a head covering. She is a professor of ethics at the Catholic Institute of Paris and the author of the recently published book Migrants, Francis, and us. Médevielle writes in defense of Amoris Laetitia against “conservatives and traditionalists” who criticize it.
The nuns were also reportedly under attack by the archbishop of Toulouse, Robert Le Gall, who prohibited one of the nuns’ houses from attending their more traditional form of Mass in their community chapel, apparently following their refusal to participate in Le Gall’s mass at the nursing home chapel due to their rejection of his liturgical practices.
Click here to read LifeSite’s November article detailing the conflict.
“Authoritarianism” and “moral harassment” from Church authorites led to destruction
The sisters’ support association is threatening to undertake legal measures against those who have brought about the destruction of the institute as an act of “moral harassment,” which is actionable under French law. The association promised that “as a matter of justice legitimate actions will be undertaken against those responsible, whatever their involvement, to obtain redress and to reveal the entire truth about this affair.”
The French Catholic newspaper La Croix further reported yesterday that the sisters “today are threatening Sister Geneviève Medevielle with a lawsuit for moral harassment.”
“It was with an authoritarianism and in a context of moral harassment, initiated by the Bishop of Laval, Mgr Scherrer, that the ecclesiastical authorities preferred to reduce the Little Sisters of Mary the Redeemer to the lay state, on 23rd May 2019, rather than opting for a peaceful solution, repeatedly proposed by the Little Sisters, but never really considered by the Congregation in Rome!” the support association declares on its website.
Our suffering enables us to live our vocation more fully, say sisters
The sisters, for their part, say they will continue to live their life of prayer and see their suffering as enabling them to live their vocation even more deeply.
“Certainly, we have not lived through these two sorrowful years in order to lose the treasure which is for us the charism received from Mother Marie de la Croix. We want to continue to live together, in a life of prayer and service. Ecce!” the sisters write.
“Paradoxically and mysteriously, we live perhaps more than ever perhaps what is at the heart of our vocation: following in the way of Our Lady, to take our part of suffering in the fulfilment of the plan of our Redemption, in reparation, for the saving of souls, for the sanctification of priests, for the Church so damaged by all sorts of scandals, for the world. If Christ, our souls’ spouse, judges us worthy of carrying such a Cross, we must render thanks to him, in all things.”
Requests for comment from the Holy See were not answered by publication time.
Previous LifeSiteNews.com coverage:
Conservative order of nuns on verge of destruction following Vatican interventions
Contact information (please be polite and respectful in all communications):
Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life:
Cardinal Prefect Joao Braz di Aviz: firstname.lastname@example.org, phone: +39. 06. 69884121
Archbishop Secretary José Rodríguez Carballo: email@example.com, phone: +39. 06. 69884584
General email form can be found here.
Information: +39. 06. 69884128; +39. 06. 69892511
Fax: +39. 06. 69884526
Association of Support for the Little Sisters of Mary, Mother of the Redeemer:
Main webpage in English: https://www.soutienpsm.com/severedifficulties
(You may also select French, Italian, or Spanish at upper right of webpage.)
Chez Mr Marcel MIGNOT
1 Avenue de Montréal
Résidence Montréal 2
72000 Le Mans
To sign the petition of support for the Little Sisters: https://www.soutienpsm.com/signer-la-petition-anglais
Click here for links to detailed coverage by the French blog Riposte Catholique (can be translated to English easily with Google Translate — in Chrome browser right click on webpage and select “Translate to English”).
Thank you for letting us know about this tragedy. I have written to them. Through The Little Sisters support association, you can send messages of support and sign the petition supporting them. The tabs on the support page will guide you. https://www.soutienpsm.com/severedifficulties
I read about their situation in French some months ago, and from what I gathered, this tragedy and scandal has been created by the local Bishop, interested both in suppressing the more traditional aspects of Catholicism in his diocese and in gaining control of the assets and properties of the Order.
True but there was collusion from the Vatican insomuch that they sent investigators who wouldn’t compromise and refused the Little Sisters appeals. The Bishop started it but others wreaked purposeful destruction.
Not sure about “collusion” — one does have to remember that each Bishop is canonically sovereign in his Diocese, so that supporting that Law, even when cases of ill consequence may arise when it is misused, does not necessarily entail complicity.
But it is certainly most sad that the competent Authorities at the Holy See did not see fit to use their own powers to either overrule the Bishop, or quite simply to accede to the initial request of these nuns to be given leave for a canonical relocation into the Authority of a different Bishop, that their present Ordinary refused.
I agree. Well explained.
This is so sad. It is also most likely to be far from the last traditional order of religious to be destroyed by the Modernists who have been infiltrating the Holy Catholic Church since the last century.
Only when an Order is living in the Diocese of a truly Catholic Bishop – e.g.: like the Franciscan Friars of the Immaculate in Gosport (England) where Bishop Philip Egan is “canonically sovereign” – can they survive… and even increase! Thanks to this good Bishop that is exactly what is happening there, Deo gratias.
The good stories give us hope but I was thinking, as I read it, that it would take less than generation in time to all but wipe out the traditional orders (through Rome or the Bishop who is sympathetic to the ’cause’). It worries me!